Do these morons really think only one photograph was taken at a mass rally? Is it finally time to have a serious conversation about the mental state of this guy??https://t.co/BJYLgj69o3
— Sheldon Whitehouse (@SenWhitehouse) August 12, 2024
Former President Donald Trump recently claimed that a photo of a large crowd at a campaign rally for Vice President Kamala Harris and her running mate, Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, in Detroit was altered using artificial intelligence (AI). Despite clear evidence to the contrary, including photos and videos captured by attendees and media organizations, Trump asserted that the crowd was fabricated. Governor Walz criticized Trump’s false claim at a fundraiser in Denver on Wednesday.
Forensics confirm authenticity of crowds in Detroit to see @VP. The "liar’s dividend" refers to ease with which real events can be called “fake” & the value of securing provenance of media in era of genAI @C2PA_org @PartnershipAI @WHOSTP @BBC @BradSmi https://t.co/3TuEkIX6kz
— Eric Horvitz (@erichorvitz) August 13, 2024
I assure you, in Detroit, that wasn’t AI, and I’ll also assure you that every one of the ballots they’re going to cast will not be AI,” Walz told the crowd, prompting cheers. The Harris campaign confirmed that the disputed photo, which showed thousands of supporters waiting for the candidates’ arrival, was taken by a campaign staffer and was not manipulated by AI. Experts, such as Hany Farid, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, specializing in forensic images, examined the photo and found no evidence of AI manipulation.
Donald Trump may be crazy, but he's not stupid.
When he claims that “nobody” showed up at a 10,000 person Harris rally in MI that was live-streamed & widely covered by the media, that it was all AI, he is laying the groundwork for rejecting the election results if he loses. pic.twitter.com/R30Tcbxkym
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) August 13, 2024
This is an example where just the mere existence of deepfakes and generative AI allows people to deny reality,” Farid said.
Trump’s false AI manipulation claim
“You don’t like the fact that Harris-Walz had such a big crowd?
No problem. Photos are fake. Videos are fake. Everything’s fake.”
If Donald Trump continues to attack @KamalaHarris and @Tim_Walz for wanting Americans to have access to affordable health care, he’s going to lose more and more support in America. pic.twitter.com/5IyLAUqCLE
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) August 12, 2024
Senator Bernie Sanders noted that the claims about the photo’s authenticity create doubt among the electorate. “If you can convince your supporters that thousands of people who attended a televised rally do not exist, it will not be hard to convince them that the election returns in Pennsylvania, Michigan, and elsewhere are ‘fake’ and ‘fraudulent,'” he said. The debate over the photo’s authenticity highlights the broader issue of trust in facts and evidence in a democratic society.
UCLA law professor Rick Hasen commented, “If voters tend to disbelieve anything they see and think that whatever they see might be faked, then they’re going to distrust their own instincts as to what the truth is to be able to make competent decisions.
As misinformation continues circulating, experts warn that it becomes increasingly challenging for the public to discern reality from fabrication, threatening the democratic process by sowing doubt and confusion among the electorate.